Siegmeyer of Catarina

siegmeyer of catarina

Siegmeyer of Catarina is a character in Dark Souls.The character was revealed in the product announcement. A knight swearing allegiance to an unidentified order of warriors, this NPC can occasionally assist the player in various points in the game. It is possible for this older gentleman knight to die in the course of aiding you, so be careful.

Siegmeyer can first be found sitting outside the entrance to Sen's Fortress, notifying the player that the gates are sealed shut. His armor set can be bought from the Crestfallen Merchant in Sen's fortress for 34,000 souls (10,000 for helm and chest armor and 7000 for the leggings and gloves). He is the father of Sieglinde of Catarina.

 

 

 

 

Encounters

Locations Events
Sen's Fortress Right outside the Gate. Prior to both Bell's of Awakening being rung.
Sen's Fortress On a ledge, below the first hill, where the rolling boulders are encountered. Prior to changing direction of boulders.
Anor Londo Deep inside the castle, past the bonfire with Solaire and a few Silver Knights spawns. After Killing the Sliver Knights, gives Tiny Being's Ring as reward.
Firelink Shrine Standing beside the Bonfire. Gives Emit Force spell as reward for help.
Blighttown Opposite end of the swamp where the boss is located, close to the The Great Hollow entrance. He asks for 3 Purple Moss Clump. He thanks you and gives you the Pierce Shield.
Lost Izalith In the room where the floor collapses, right before the Poison Marsh. Will help kill the demons below. Reward varies dependent on outcome.
Ash Lake First Bonfire after The Great Hollow. See details below:

 

Guide of Siegmeyer of Catarina's Events


First Encounter: Siegmeyer will be outside Sen's Fortress waiting for the gates to open. You can talk to him and you'll get some dialogue, but this encounter is skippable. Ringing both bells makes him move to a new location.

Second Encounter: Siegmeyer will be located inside Sen's Fortress on a ledge near the part where you deal with the boulders for the first time. This encounter is also skippable (you do not need to talk to him to progress the quest) but to make him move to his new location you must turn the boulder machine until the boulders are redirected to empty space.

Third Encounter: He will be in the castle, in Anor Londo. When you finally make it up to the rooftop where an Silver Knight Archer is guarding the spiral staircase down to the main floor/bonfire there will be another parapet off to the left with another Black Knight guarding inside. After you defeat him, head down the spiral staircase and speak to Siegmeyer who is standing outside a room with 3 Silver Knights in it. After defeating the 3 knights, speak to him again and he will give you the Tiny Being's Ring. This step and the following ones are NOT skippable.

Fourth Encounter: After beating Anor Londo/Acquiring Lordvessel, warp back to Firelink Shrine. Siegmeyer should be standing by the fire. Speak to him and he will ask if you rang both the bells to open Sen's Fortress. Say yes and he will give you the "Emit Force" miracle. Say no and he wont. After answering yes, speak to him again and he will say that he is going to head down below for an adventure in Blighttown. Changing areas will make him disappear from Firelink.

Fifth Encounter: Come back to Firelink Shrine and you will notice that Siegmeyer is missing. Head down to the swamp bonfire in Blighttown. From the fire, head northwest towards the leech area/tree branch that leads to The Great Hollow. Keep running past it and you should see him standing on a little island. He will be asleep so speak to him twice. He will wake up and ask for some Purple Moss Clumps. Give them to him and he will give you the Pierce Shield.

Finding his daughter: While heading through The Duke's Archives, right before the entrance to Crystal Cave there are multiple Blue Crystal Golems around. You should see a Gold Crystal Golem in the middle of this forest area. He is extremely strong compared to the blue ones, so be careful. Defeat this Gold Crystal Golem and Sieglinde, his daughter, will pop out. Speak to her and she will ask if you have seen her father. Say "yes" and she will thank you and nothing more. Warp back to Firelink Shrine. You will see Seiglinde here. Speak with her once and say that you have seen her "father" again.

Sixth Encounter: You will find Siegmeyer in Lost Izalith, in the room above the Chaos Eaters. Do NOT speak with him yet. The outcome of his quest line has THREE possibilities here:

  • Option 1: If Siegmeyer ends up with more than 50% HP after the battle, he will then move to Ash Lake (near the first bonfire) where he will meet his end. His daughter, Sieglinde of Catarina will be standing next to him, and give you a Titanite Slab, finishing the questline. To accomplish this (it can be tricky) the best way is to kill all but one of the Chaos Eaters before talking to him, then talk to him and quickly jump down and kill the last Chaos Eater and talk again to Siegmeyer, if he has more than 50% of HP will say he just needs a rest. A desperate maneuver you can do, if you see Siegmeyer is getting surrounded by many Chaos Eaters, is to quickly quit the game and reload. Siegmeyer will appear a bit far from the center of the swamp giving you time to finish the Chaos Demons. The Chaos Eaters will also try a special grab attack on Siegmeyer, if you see them grabbing Siegmeyer, quickly quit the game so the game saves before Siegmeyer receives the damage, then reload and kill the remaining Chaos Eaters. ‍Note:‍ this step can be done before the "Finding his daughter step". Just make sure you answer yes to both the questions of Sieglinde.

 

  • Option 2: If Siegmeyer finishes the battle with less than 50% HP, he will be too badly wounded to stay alive for long, he will give you a Speckled Stoneplate Ring and then perish. The questline ends.

 

  • Option 3: You can kill all the Chaos Eaters before talking to him. He will give you the Speckled Stoneplate Ring thanking you for saving him again and claiming he is too weak; the questline will end, but he will survive.

Notes

  • IMPORTANT If you attack Siegmeyer and he becomes aggressive he will still be aggressive at later encounters
  • Keep in mind that the poison of the Chaos Eater labyrinth will damage Siegmeyer, so you may want to homeward bone or quit the game fast after you deal with the Chaos Eaters to avoid getting him too hurt. (This seemed to be a bug as it no longer happens as of version 1.06)
  • The Chaos Eaters that are in the poison floor under Siegmeyer (Lost Izalith), DO NOT respawn. Don't kill them before you get Siegmeyer there or you will be stuck at the Option 3.
  • Avoid using AoE attacks, as Siegmeyer can be damaged by your attacks while fighting the Chaos Eaters in Lost Izalith.
  • You have to talk to Sieglinde at Firelink Shrine after helping Siegmeyer in Lost Izalith to make them appear in Ash Lake.

    Video Guide of Siegmeyer of Catarina's Events

Gifts

Item Condition
Emit Force Report that you've opened the gate to Sen's Fortress by ringing both bells.
Tiny Being's Ring Report that you've killed all the Silver Knights in the room next to where he appears in Anor Londo.
Pierce Shield Giving him a Purple Moss Clump in Blightown.
Speckled Stoneplate Ring Killing all the Chaos Eaters before talking to him, or having him end the battle with them below 50% health.

 

Drops

 

Character Info

 

 




Tired of anon posting? Register!
    • Anonymous

      Siegmeyer got pushed down by the snakes in sen's fortress ... it wasn't even my fault, goodbye titanite slab

      • Anonymous

        I killed two of them early on and when we jumped down together I gave both the finishing blows... He then apologised for failing me and committed seppuku...

        • Anonymous

          I’m pretty sure everyone can agree when I say the way you can fail siegmeyer’s quest line in lost izalith is hella stupid

          • Anonymous

            As others have mentioned, if trying for Option 1, there is a hidden Chaos Eater in the pit to the right of where you jump down. Have forgotten this on more than one occasion and ended up screwing up his questline because he charges it and dies or loses too much health.

            • Anonymous

              So I spoke to him and jumped in the pit after he went down there and I immediately got killed since the fall dmg took most my health and then a chaos eater got me. I walked back from the bonfire expecting to see his corpse next to my bloodstain. All the enemies but one are dead and he is fighting the last one, I jump in to help finish that guy off. So I am blown away expecting him to at least fall over dead at this point, no way he has above 50 percent hp right? Well he immediately takes a nap.... which according to this guide means he LIVES!

              • Anonymous

                "The Chaos Eaters that are in the poison floor under Siegmeyer (Lost Izalith), DO NOT respawn."
                lol of course. Back to farming Darkwraiths for a million aeons :)

                • Anonymous

                  I didn't know you should've killed the Chaos Eaters before talking to Siegmeyer, so he jumped into them and immediately got clapped :(

                  • Anonymous

                    So, I looked in the hole and saw 4 little big *****es in it. Got 3, spare the 3rd one. Asked Siegmeyer for help, he jumped down and destroy the last one, but, BUT, there is another little ***** hiding in the right! Goddamn it! It is the respawning one. So I wasn't paying attention, then suddenly that guy came out and Sieg got that red thingy on him. I was scared, so I went back. Upped my faith all the way up to 36, learnt the team healing spell, joined Great Chest Covenant. Took 1 hour or so backstabbing those guys at the garden with my dragon tooth and illusory spell, because I was already at a high level. After all that ****, I went back. Gywnevere's ring, and that spell. I can even see it affecting him properly, don't lie to me. And yet he still died. Why? I kinda already knew it won't work, since the moment we are done with the battle it is already coded in, but this still suck. At least give the players the chance to fix it, Fromsoft!

                    • Anonymous

                      Dude I killed all Chaos Eaters in like 5 sec and they didn't even touched Siegmeyer but he died anyway. And I killed the Eaters so fast he attacked me by accident, didn't dealt any damage tho xD My guess is that it was either a bug or he dies of poison too which is annoying either way :(

                      • Anonymous

                        bro I thought there were only 4, I let 1 live for Sieg to kill but then there was another one and he is low now.

                        • Anonymous

                          I'm fairly new to darksouls as I got the gane 2 weeks ago but in my newgame plus plus,solaire and onion man and onion daughter aren't spawning at all,I haven't been to ash Lake yet and I didnt kill either of them although I did kill solaire by accident in my first okay through any ideas why this is happening?

                          • Hey Im having a problem.
                            Siegmeyer doesn't appear in Anor Londo, I have already moved the boulder.
                            The thing is that I killed Gwynevere and I'm in dark Anor Londo, also I have already placed the Lordvessel.
                            Have I screwed it up?

                            • Anonymous

                              becareful not to use homing soul mass spell, or aoe spells. it can attack siegmeyer and fail your questline when in izalith.

                              • Anonymous

                                Tried going for option 1, but I aggroed all Chaos Eaters, they followed me and all suicided into a hole in the ground without me hitting any one of them. Since they don't respawn I got stack at option 3.

                                • Anonymous

                                  i killed a bunch of chaos eaters before killing centipede (had izalith skip) after killing the centipede me and onion bro jumped down and killed the last two, after that he didn't give me anything, then he just stayed in that area for the rest of the game, very strange, he didn't even move to ash lake, just stayed there... forever...

                                  • Anonymous

                                    When I went in the poison pit, I only found 1 chaos eater. I killed it thinking there's more since the guide for option 1 says so. I didn't find any other chaos eater except for the one on the platform above the poison pit, which I left alive. I proceeded by talking to Siegmeyer who immediately says I've already killed everything. As soon as he said that I alt+f4, because that's not what I wanted. When I got back in game, I went to a bonfire to try and make the chaos eaters respawn, to no avail, Siegmeyer was still there, but there was not a single chaos eater in the poison pit anymore. No choice but to accept the ring and rip titanite slab.
                                    I'm playing Dark Souls Remastered v1.01. I don't know if they made changes to this event or what, but to anyone still having to complete this event: watch out, make sure there's more than one chaos eater down there and make sure you leave something alive, because they don't respawn using the bonfire.

                                    • Anonymous

                                      Probably worth mentioning that one of the chaos eaters in the pit doesn't count for the quest, and if you leave just that one you will fail option 1. Frustrating way to fail the quest especially when following a guide lol

                                      • Anonymous

                                        They are just poorly done. Characters are interesting but there is no way you can interact with them, like telling Sieg about his daughter or telling Rhea that she is about to get murdered and so on and so on. This game wouldve bee so much better if it had some dialog options. I am not one of those dudes who want to be able to save them all, cuz some should die because its dark souls but in some stupidly obvious moments we should be able to change the outcome of things. All From does is just killing everyone in last step of their questlines like Sieg for now reason. I just met Big hat logan before he goes insane and he is 100% fine, i don't see any reason for him going hollow right on the spot.
                                        And anyway i am tired of characters going hollow like after 1 death, why cant they respawn many times like we do? Ds1 is especially stupid finishing off almost every character out there. Why can i tell Anastasia that she is fine lad and should stop talking nonsense about her tongue being ripped off? Game is legendary, characters are glorious, setups and encounters are amzaing, but story telling and endigs just suck ass, just like the whole series. Was there even a single npc who said something about dying recently and respawning again?
                                        Why is Andre of Astora... oh okay i am tired. **** off with these questlines, i am gonna imagine my own endings too everything in this game

                                        • why exactly would i want to choose option 1? he dies at option 1 or 2 anyway, and in case of option 2, i get the ring at least, there are other sources to get the titanite slab from option 1. and if i want to let him stay alive, i would have to go for option 3 anyway

                                          • Anonymous

                                            The questline ending is unfu**ing believable... i dont think i ever felt so much emotion with any questline of any dark souls... I feel empty, soulless, emotionless.... FUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK THIS GAME

                                            • Anonymous

                                              THIS GUY IS A RIP OFF OF BIORR TWIN FANGS **** DARK SOULS **** FROM SOFTWARE **** KINGS FIELD **** 3D DOT HEROES AND FUUUUCCKK YOOOU SIEGMEYER!!!!

                                              • Anonymous

                                                I love how everyone is complaining about the NPC storylines and dont get the point.
                                                If you didnt use a guide in the first place, you will get a different experience every time you play this game. The only thing you can complain about is, that they should never tied to an achievement you can miss.

                                                • Anonymous

                                                  these questlines are outrageous. do this in a specific things in a ridiculous way and better pray that you didnt mess up or read the wiki before progressing the game at all. fun part of all this is that if you mess up once, you have to start a completely new game if you want another try at it. and hope you dont mess up again...

                                                  • Anonymous

                                                    Short:
                                                    If you answer Yes to Sieglinde at first in Crystal Cave but then say No in Firelink Shrine, you can still get the Titanite Slab.

                                                    Long:
                                                    While playing Remastered, I answered Yes to Sieglinde after rescuing her from the Gold Crystal Golem in Crystal Caves, but then I went to Firelink Shrine and answered No. She disappeared. I also hadn't seen Siegmeyer in Blighttown near The Great Hollow Entrance yet. I went to see him, and then did the proper steps in Izalith (killed all but 1 monster around the area down below, talked to him, he jumpted down, I jumped down AND AVOIDED HIM, then went and killed the last monster before the guy hurt himself. He talked about needing a rest and started sleeping while standing, like usual. I went to Firelink Shrine and Sieglinde was there, she talked about her father going on an adventure or whatever. I went to Ash Lake and there they were, I got the Titanite Slab.

                                                    • Anonymous

                                                      If Siegmeyer and Sieglinde are both representatives of their country, then Catarina must be the friendliest country on earth.

                                                      • Anonymous

                                                        So I killed all the demons but one, like this guide told me. Too bad that the last idiot tried to follow me and killed himself by jumping into a pit.
                                                        Now i failed the quest and Siegmeyer is depressed...
                                                        I hate NPC questline in these games.

                                                        • Anonymous

                                                          I really dislike the convoluted NPC quests in these games. I get them done about 2/3 without using a guide and then OOPS you didn't drink an Estus next to the statue in the beginning of the game behind the illusory wall that only disappears if you have a special item from the deadly swamp area nobody ever explores. NPC go poof.

                                                          • Anonymous

                                                            so I killed O&S before talking to him in Anor Londo, but the wiki claims you need to pick up the lord vessel before he moves yet he isn't in Anor Londo, am I just ****ed?

                                                            • Anonymous

                                                              There's another outcome to the Izalith encounter. If you die, but he survives and kills all the chaos eaters, then respawn and return to him, he tells you he failed you, and overcome with depression, he dies. Probably the most frustrating way to fail the quest.

                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                The absolute worst questline. Oh no you looked at Siegemeyer the wrong way and he died better luck next run ;)

                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                  Y'know, NPCs in this game aren't the brightest. Maybe, if the player is doing a horizontal swing with an ultra greatsword to kill one of those demon things, you're first reaction should not be to run right into the swing and aggro on the player, Siegmeyer. I had to waste 39000 souls to absolve my sins for something that wasn't even my fault.

                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                    Siegmeyer isn't in Blightown, I heard all his dialouges, but he remains there at Firelink.
                                                                    I even reloaded the game and the area, I killed a boss, killed Seath, placed the Lord Vessel...
                                                                    If someone else had this problem too and solvedcit, please reply.

                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                      I quit the game without saving before even meeting him in Anor Londo, near the mimics. When I get to his spot he is gone. I did everything right but did quitting and reloading kill him?

                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                        Just messed this up in the stupidest way. Killed all but 1 Eater in the Izalith pool, talked to Siegmeyer, he jumped down into the pool and I followed... landing on top of him which he took as aggression and I had no choce but to end him. All that for nothing.

                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                          I left one of the ones in the pit alive but when I came back with Siegmeyer there the final one was killed anyway. Not sure how many you have to leave alive

                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                            I killed the 4 just in the pit opening in lost izalith but not the two others that wander around near the pit exits for siegmeyer to kill. It seems that he only looks at those 4 and will go to option 3 even if there are still the stragglers left, ending the questline.

                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                              You do not have to obtain to the lord vessel for the 4th encounter.

                                                                              I'm not sure exactly what causes him to move to firelink. Maybe just reloading the area/game?

                                                                              Very helpful for shield only run, as you can get the pierce shield for O&S

                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                I used the dark hand to give Sieg a bro hug (of sorts) before both of us jumped into the pit because i didn’t clear any of them out prior and I didn’t know what the outcome would be. After a solid battle he unfortunately lost too much health and perished afterwards but at least it wasn’t during the fight itself. What a guy RIP

                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                  If all the chaos eaters die (they accidentally fell off the hole in the swamp), can i reload the area? On previous playthroughs where i don't follow the questline i always saw at least 1 chaos eater after all of them die

                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                    Everyone's complaining about how trash his Fighting skills are,.but nobody's talking about how impressive it is that an onion learned how the wield an ultragreatsword! Go onion power!

                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                      This explanation is ****! You need to specify that you will not get the slab if doing option 2! You ****tards.

                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                        So a few things I noticed in Ash Lake. I managed to peek inside their helmets:

                                                                                        1: Siegmeyer wasn't hollow. He still looked human. Not only that, his eyes are blinking.
                                                                                        2: Sieglinde is smiling.

                                                                                        Now this may have just been limitations or cutbacks in the design, you can't really see their faces anyway with the helmets the way they are. However, I like to think there's a deeper plot afoot. Maybe Seiglinde wanted to kill her father for some reason, and it's not the first time she has. She openly says that if he goes hollow, she'll have to kill him *again*. Now maybe Seigmeyer was somehow aware that she wanted to finish him off and in a battle with her he managed to fake his death in order to stop her from following him. Maybe the stories she tells us of how he keeps adventuring and disappearing aren't quite true. Maybe she wanted to find him because she intended to end him from the start All the areas he shows up in are quite perilous to get to, possibly proving he may be trying to escape her. He's going places she'd be more hesitant to search. Maybe she's not actually his daughter at all and she's an assassin that dons the disguise of a Catarina knight in order to fool others into leading her close to him.

                                                                                        Or maybe, just maybe, I'm just pulling this idea out of my backside.

                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                          This guy blows I put all the chaos eater 1 hit away from death with arrows and he instantly melted as soon as he jumped in

                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                            So I finished his quest to Ash Lake where his daughter had killed him. I took out my binoculars to get a view of his face. When I did, I noticed his eyes were blinking open and closed! Has anyone else noticed this small detail? He's a faker!

                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                              For some reason, not Siegmeyer nor Sieglinde showed up at Ash Lake. I had done all of the encounters, had him at about 80% hp after the Chaos Eaters, saved his daughter and met with her at Firelink, and when i at long last arrive at Ash Lake, there's nothing here but the inbred lake snake and his cluster of crappy, quadrupedal, clattering, crustacean comrades.

                                                                                              Somebody please help me

                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                Not sure if I screwed up his questline...I killed the Iron Golem before rotating the boulder lever. Got to his spot in Anor Londo and realized my mistake, so I backtracked and hit the lever in Sen's Fortress. But he's still not in Anor Londo....did I mess up? Or is this fixable?

                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                  Damn the final encounter with him and Sieglinde in Ash Lake with it’s gloomy music is probably the most depressing thing in the game

                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                    Forgot to talk to him at Sen's Fortress, and now he doesn't show up in Anor Londo. I'm wondering if killing the Silver Knights will fix the quest or break it to pieces

                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                      This happy, daring and proud knight in shiny onion armor is my official Husbando. Sorry Solaire, I like guys with curves and cakes in the right place.

                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                        I tried to kill all but one chaos eater to make things easier, but the dumb ****ers followed me everywhere and killed themselves in the pits. There goes my quest...

                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                          You probably shouldn’t worry too much about the Izalith encounter going wrong, I jumped down with Siegmeyer with every chaos eater alive and he killed 3 together while I got 1. It may have been good RNG but he really made quick work of them. I wa*****ting the only chaos eater I defeated and to the left of my screen I seen the other 3 pancaked all together by his Zweihander, dudes a monster when he needs to be.

                                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                                            I wouldn’t worry too much about the Lost Izalith encounter. I dropped down with Sieg with every chaos eater alive in my recent playthrough and he killed 3 of them while I only fought one. As I was taking it down I seen the other 3 get flattened by his Zweihander all at once, he’s a monster when he needs to be. It might have been good RNG but it seems reliable to dive straight in rather than kill some before talking to him unless you have a bow which is a safe strategy. Lastly, never ever come down from the side to enter the area with the chaos eaters because they will walk straight into the huge pitfalls one by one and it’ll fail the quest.

                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                              From everything you've heard so far, the solemn Catarina must be a wonderful, friendly country. In the stark context of Lordran.

                                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                                I would like it to be noted that there is at least one way to save this quest late in the game if you f'd up as long as you don't beat a boss in between these events.

                                                                                                                I stupidly forgot to save Sieglinde in the Dukes Archives before I saved/helped Siegmeyer from the Chaos eaters.
                                                                                                                I quickly made a trip back to the archives, saved her then talked to her at firelink and told her where her dad was.
                                                                                                                After that I popped down to ash lake and there she was standing over her dad being sad.
                                                                                                                She then gave me the slab and that was that.

                                                                                                                So as long as you do not beat any bosses and you are at the part with the Chaos Eaters, you can save Sieglinde or Siegmeyer first.
                                                                                                                (Or maybe it's a bug, but I don't think it is).
                                                                                                                I'll try again in ng+ and post a comment on this to confirm.

                                                                                                                -LuckyCATCH

                                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                                  I stupidly followed the quest how the game intends you to, with both of us fighting the chaos eaters. We jumped down, and he got one-shotted instantly. Thank you Dark Souls.

                                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                                    Check out this guy in anor londo being all like: Hmmm we need more people to defeat three silver knights, i accidentally aggro him with WoG and he starts Annihilating the silver knights with one hit, he then two-shots me shortly after.

                                                                                                                    Exactly who needs help here?

                                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                                      Came here as I was unsure if you could kill them while standing ontop with Siegmeyer or just bring them low enough to 1 shot. even then, he somehow got damaged to below the red tearstone ring cap. The chaos eaters did in less than 3 seconds. He shouldn't be so fragile if you need him at more than 50% hp in order to not miss a slab.

                                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                                        I end his quest with option 3 to get the ring. I know it’s very tedious to get slabs from Darkwraiths but the idea of choosing the slab which is farmable over the ring which can only be obtained from this quest really bugs me. I think it’s my collector addiction because the ring isn’t very useful and most would do well to choose the slab over it I just know I can’t

                                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                                          To this day I don't quite understand something and it actually sounds pretty creepy. In conversation with his daughter, she says "if he were to become a hollow, then I would have to kill him - again". What exactly does she mean by that? Like that she has killed him at some point, or that he will be killed again after being killed by Lordran's dangers or enemies?

                                                                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                                                                            In Lost Izalith, I had no idea you had to only kill 3
                                                                                                                            chaos eaters because I saw 5 down there. I killed the first four and left the 5th one before talking to him and he gave me the speckled stoneplate ring as if I had killed them all for him. Now I'm not gonna get that Titanite Slab. I wish there were more than two in the base game like in DS3.

                                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                                              Sooo... Accidentally killed his daughter due to a crystal golem attacking her then her getting too close in the middle of a combo, so what now? I've gotten him past the chaos eaters and he's sleeping (so over 50% health), what happens next? Did I totally FUBAR it?

                                                                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                If you angle your camera correctly in Ash Lake you can see through his helmet. It’s definitely just an oversight, but he’s not hollow and his eyes are still blinking. Kinda creepy.

                                                                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                  I didn't pay attention and *****ed the Lost Izalith part up. I killed all of the CEs and left one, talked to him once, and then killed the last one. What I didn't do was talk to him the SECOND time, the one that actually prompts him to jump down. Well, at least he survived and I got a really useful ring.

                                                                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                    DO NOT jump down before talking to Siegmeyer to kill all but one of them. The last one up will try to follow you as you make your way to the stairs and end up falling into a pit, killing itself. Ruined my quest for this play through. Take your chances talking to him and jumping down to take them all on together.

                                                                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                      There appears to be a 5th option? I rescued Siglinde from the Golden Crystal Golem and spoke with her twice in Firelink before helping Siegmeyer fight the Chaos Eaters and survive with more than half HP. Siegmeyer starts sleeping and returning to Firelink has a conversation with Siglinde saying that she found her father, that he's fine, and that he's gone on another adventure. She mentions that if he goes hollow again, she'll just have to kill him again, but this conversation was in Firelink, not in Ash Lake. I was never rewarded a Slab or Ring for this. Neither character does anything else now.

                                                                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                        There is, indeed, a fourth option. If you accidentally hit him during the Chaos Eater fight, you will be forced to kill him. He drops the 3 humanity and the speckled stone plate ring. I cry.

                                                                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                          Well the daughter killed him in the first place WTF. If immediately after Lost Izalith with Sieg >50% & having said yes to daughter twice, go to Firelink shrine to speak to daughter where she says “he went on final adventure, if hollow she’ll just have to kill him AGAIN”

                                                                                                                                          • I had done everything right until the encounter in Lost Izalith, then got an invader that killed all the Chaos Eaters before I had a chance to locate him and realize what he (or she, you never know) was up to. Screwed my chances of getting the titanite slab. So when you get to that point, I recommend playing offline if you really want that slab!

                                                                                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                                                                                              Tough son of a gun. I was on my first play through and didn’t expect him to actually jump into the pit with eaters and I died immediately of panic. So I respawned, realized my weapon was near broken, warped to Andre, fixed weapon, accidentally hit Andre, ran to Oswald to absolve sin and realized I didn’t have enough souls, warped back to daughter of chaos bonfire, ran back to Siegmeyer and found the guy still fighting. We finished off the eaters and he still had more than half health left. Heck.

                                                                                                                                            Load more
                                                                                                                                            ⇈ ⇈